Carolin
Schurr

READ MORE

Carolin Schurr is professor of Social and Cultural Geography at the University of Bern. She is the principal investigator of the SNSF project "Reproductive Geopolitics" project. MORE

Laura
Perler

READ MORE

Laura Perler is a postdoctoral researcher in Social and Cultural Geography at the University of Bern. In her research she investigates inequalities in relation to reproductive technologies and the Swiss asylum system.  MORE

Nora
Komposch

READ MORE

Nora Komposch is a PhD student and assistant in Social and Cultural Geography at the University of Bern. She researches about migrant workers in Spain's strawberry industry. MORE

Mirko
Winkel

READ MORE

Mirko Winkel is the coordinator of the mLAB. The artist and curator teaches at the University of Bern and other places with the aim of synthesizing art with scientific research and socio-political concerns.

Yolinliztli
Pérez-Hernández

READ MORE

Yolinliztli Pérez-Hernández is a PostDoc in Social and Cultural Geography. She researches the experiences of sterilization (tubal ligation and hysterectomy) of low-income, rural, peasant, and indigenous Mexican women as part of national family planning and global birth control policies in developing countries. MORE  

Lucy Sabin

READ MORE

Lucy Sabin is an artistic researcher with a background in media and geography. Her work explores air and breathing, chemical exposures, feminist science studies, and environmental justice. Sabin holds a postdoctoral position in the Department of Ethics, Law, and Humanities at Amsterdam UMC. Her portfolio is available at aerography.uk 

Milena
Wegelin

READ MORE

Milena Wegelin is a social anthropologist and research associate at the Department of Perinatal and Maternal Health of the Bern University of Applied Sciences. Sie is collaborating with Laura Perler in her subproject “Governing and Contesting In/fertility within the Swiss Asylum Context”

Susanne
Schultz

READ MORE

Susanne Schultz is lecturer at the Department of Sociology at the Goethe University Frankfurt a.M. She is a visiting researcher who collaborates with the team of the project „Reproductive Geopolitics“ with a SNSF Scientific Exchange Grant in 2023. MORE

Veronika
Siegl

READ MORE

Veronika Siegl, holding a PostDoctoral position in Social and Cultural Geography, is a social anthropologist and gender researcher. Her research focuses on ethics, inequality and self-determination in the context of reproductive medicine.   MORE

CLOSE
Yolinliztli Pérez-Hernández
2023
Belgium
egg freezing
France
genetic relatedness
Michiel De Proost
motherhood
qualitative research

Egg freezing, genetic relatedness, and motherhood:A binational empirical bioethical investigation of women's views

Yolinliztli Pérez-Hernández, Michiel De Proost

Abstract

Genetic relatedness figures heavily in contemporary ethical debates on egg freezing,although the arguments lack empirical‐based evidence. Rather than adding another theoretical view on the moral relevance of genetic connections, this paper instead proposes an empirically grounded perspective based on two independent qualitative interview‐based studies conducted in Belgium and France. Three themes emerge from our empirical data: (1) prioritizing family building; (2) centering the gestational experience of motherhood; and (3) identifying the complexities and limitations of adoption. These themes suggest that the relationship between egg freezing,genetics, biological motherhood, and adoption is highly complex and less straightforward than what is often assumed in the egg freezing debate. Our study provides more detailed insights into women’s ambivalent experiences regarding those reproductive options. We discuss the ethical implications of our empirical findings and hold that pursuing genetic desire is not necessarily the main moral reason why women freeze their eggs.

Full Text

Pérez-Hernández, Y., & De Proost, M. (2023). Egg freezing, genetic relatedness, and motherhood: A binational empirical bioethical investigation of women’s views. Bioethics, 1–8. https://doi.org/10.1111/bioe.13163